diff --git a/Content.Server/Whitelist/WhitelistCommands.cs b/Content.Server/Whitelist/WhitelistCommands.cs
index c503c8453c..59b576e7ca 100644
--- a/Content.Server/Whitelist/WhitelistCommands.cs
+++ b/Content.Server/Whitelist/WhitelistCommands.cs
@@ -31,10 +31,17 @@ public sealed class AddWhitelistCommand : IConsoleCommand
             var guid = data.UserId;
             var isWhitelisted = await db.GetWhitelistStatusAsync(guid);
             if (isWhitelisted)
+            {
+                shell.WriteLine(Loc.GetString("command-whitelistadd-existing", ("username", data.Username)));
                 return;
+            }
 
             await db.AddToWhitelistAsync(guid);
+            shell.WriteLine(Loc.GetString("command-whitelistadd-added", ("username", data.Username)));
+            return;
         }
+
+        shell.WriteError(Loc.GetString("command-whitelistadd-not-found", ("username", args[0])));
     }
 }
 
@@ -60,10 +67,17 @@ public sealed class RemoveWhitelistCommand : IConsoleCommand
             var guid = data.UserId;
             var isWhitelisted = await db.GetWhitelistStatusAsync(guid);
             if (!isWhitelisted)
+            {
+                shell.WriteLine(Loc.GetString("command-whitelistremove-existing", ("username", data.Username)));
                 return;
+            }
 
             await db.RemoveFromWhitelistAsync(guid);
+            shell.WriteLine(Loc.GetString("command-whitelistremove-removed", ("username", data.Username)));
+            return;
         }
+
+        shell.WriteError(Loc.GetString("command-whitelistremove-not-found", ("username", args[0])));
     }
 }
 
diff --git a/Resources/Locale/en-US/connection-messages.ftl b/Resources/Locale/en-US/connection-messages.ftl
index a17b202718..752dacac66 100644
--- a/Resources/Locale/en-US/connection-messages.ftl
+++ b/Resources/Locale/en-US/connection-messages.ftl
@@ -3,9 +3,15 @@ whitelist-not-whitelisted-rp = You are not whitelisted. To become whitelisted, v
 
 command-whitelistadd-description = Adds the player with the given username to the server whitelist.
 command-whitelistadd-help = whitelistadd <username>
+command-whitelistadd-existing = {$username} is already on the whitelist!
+command-whitelistadd-added = {$username} added to the whitelist
+command-whitelistadd-not-found = Unable to find '{$username}'
 
 command-whitelistremove-description = Removes the player with the given username from the server whitelist.
 command-whitelistremove-help = whitelistremove <username>
+command-whitelistremove-existing = {$username} is not on the whitelist!
+command-whitelistremove-removed = {$username} removed from the whitelist
+command-whitelistremove-not-found = Unable to find '{$username}'
 
 command-kicknonwhitelisted-description = Kicks all non-whitelisted players from the server.
 command-kicknonwhitelisted-help = kicknonwhitelisted